Court rules out-of-state e-commerce sellers not controlling stocks exempted them from in-state tax liabilities
Pennsylvania court has ruled that out-of-state sellers using Amazon’s Fulfilment by Amazon (FBA) service are not subject to local sales tax. The case was brought by a seller association, Online Merchants Guild, which has a similar case due for hearing in October 2022 in California.
The Court held that since sellers did not control or know when and how their stocks were transferred into the state by Amazon FBA, they were not liable to the sales tax. Case ref: Online Merchants Guild v. Hassell, Pa. Commw. Ct. No. 179 MD 2021, 9/9/2022. The court commented: “We are hard pressed to envision how, in these circumstances, an FBA Merchant has placed its merchandise in the stream of commerce with the expectation that it would be purchased by a customer located in the Commonwealth, or has availed itself of the Commonwealth’s protections, opportunities, and services.”
Amazon has been collecting sales tax on FBA sellers in Pennsylvania since 2018.
Pennsylvania’s state tax rate is 6% for remote sellers. Sellers within the state may be subject to other local municipalities and city taxes added up to a further 2%.
South Dakota vs Wayfair remote seller sales tax ruling
Following the July 2018 US Supreme Court Wayfair ruling, states have been free to levy sales tax on out-of-state sellers. Pennsylvania imposed Wayfair from 1 July 2019 for remote sellers with annual sales in the state above US$100,00.
US Sales Tax rates and selling thresholds
| State | State sales tax rate | Remote seller annual thresholds | Digital services taxable? | |||||
| $ threshold | Transactions threshold | |||||||
| Alabama | 4.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $250,000 | Yes | ||||
| Alaska | 0% | - | n/a | No state-wide tax | ||||
| Arizona | 5.6% | 1 Oct 2019 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Arkansas | 6.5% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| California | 6.0% | 1 April 2019 | $500,000 | - | No | |||
| Colorado | 2.9% | 1 Dec 2018 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Connecticut | 6.35% | 1 Dec 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Delaware | 0.0% | - | n/a | No state sales tax | ||||
| Florida | 6.0% | 1 July 2021 | $100,000 | - | No | Communications Tax. E-books exempt | ||
| Georgia | 4.0% | 1 Jan 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | No | |||
| Hawaii | 4.0% | 1 July 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | General Excise Tax | ||
| Idaho | 6.0% | 1 June 2019 | $100,000 | Yes | Software exempt | |||
| Illinois | 6.25% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | No | |||
| Indiana | 7.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | - (since Jan 2024) | Yes | |||
| Iowa | 6.0% | 1 Jan 2019 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Kansas | 6.5% | 1 July 2021 | $100,000 | - | No | |||
| Kentucky | 6.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Louisiana | 4.45% | 1 July 2020 | $100,000 | - (since Aug 2023) | Yes | |||
| Maine | 5.5% | 1 July 2018 | $100,000 | - (since 2022) | Yes | |||
| Maryland | 6.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Massachusetts | 5.6% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | No | ||||
| Michigan | 6.0% | 30 Sep 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | No | |||
| Minnesota | 6.875% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Mississippi | 7.0% | 1 Sep 2018 | $250,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Missouri | 4.225% | 1 Jan 2023 | $100,000 | - | No | |||
| Montana | 0.0% | - | n/a | No state sales tax | ||||
| Nebraska | 5.5% | 1 April 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Nevada | 4.6% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | No | |||
| New Hampshire | 0.0% | - | n/a | |||||
| New Jersey | 6.625% | 1 Nov 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| New Mexico | 5.0% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| New York | 4.0% | 21 July 2018 | $500,000 | 100 transactions | No | |||
| North Carolina | 4.75% | 1 Nov 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| North Dakota | 5.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | - | No | |||
| Ohio | 5.75% | 1 Aug 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Oklahoma | 4.5% | 1 Nov 2019 | $100,000 | - | No | |||
| Oregon | 0.0% | - | n/a | No state sales tax | ||||
| Pennsylvania | 6.0% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | Yes | ||||
| Puerto Rico | 10.5% | 1 Jan 2021 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Rhode Island | 7.0% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| South Carolina | 6.0% | 1 Nov 2018 | $100,000 | - | No | |||
| South Dakota | 4.5% | 1 Nov 2018 | $100,000 | - (since Jul 2023) | Yes | |||
| Tennessee | 7.0% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Texas | 6.25% | 1 Oct 2019 | $500,000 | - | Yes | Only if physcial equivilaent is taxable (e.g. books) | ||
| Utah | 4.7% | 1 Jan 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Vermont | 6.0% | 1 July 2018 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Virginia | 4.3% | 1 July 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| Washington | 6.5% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | - | Yes | |||
| Washington, DC | 6.0% | 1 Jan 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | |||
| West Virginia | 6.0% | 1 Jan 2019 | $100,000 | 200 transactions | Yes | Streaming services only | ||
| Wisconsin | 5.0% | 1 Oct 2018 | $100,000 | - (since 2021) | Yes | |||
| Wyoming | 4.0% | 1 Feb 2019 | $100,000 | - (since 2024) | Yes | |||
